It's not pin the tail on the donkey ... it's stick the eye patch on the pirate.
Pirate Eye Patches printable party game comes in two sheets, the Pirate Face and a sheet of eye patches to stick on one or both eyes.
The priate game is a free printable for home or classroom use.
Don't need a game? You could use the pirate face to make a mask and the eye patches separately for quick, inexpensive pirate costume accessories.